[He doesn't think she is. That's the worst thing about this. He knows Kay isn't a liar. He just desperately, desperately hopes she's wrong.]

Maybe it's a mock-up, or--or something like that. Or. A misprint he didn't wanna throw out because something like Tattlecrime could find it. We shouldn't just, we can't just...accuse him without hearing what he's gotta say for himself. Did you ask him about what you saw?