[He looks a little surprised that she just came out and said it, and for a second, she might notice that his eyes are yellow and pupils slit before they return to normal.]

Well, that depends. I also referenced lizard people who aren't me.

[Because by the very nature of things, he could only be one lizard person. He wasn't going to bother hiding it, though, because enough people knew he was a lizard person that she'd find out sooner or later. Heck, even most of the natives knew what he was.]